| Year | Senior | Super Senior-Louise Starzenski Cup |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Sue Kahler | Linda Kolnick |
| 2024 | Sue Kahler | Roxy Birdsall |
| 2023 | Mary Scatena | Linda Kolnick |
| 2022 | Heidi Harkins | Linda Kolnick |
| 2021 | Sue Kahler | Linda Kolnick |
| 2020 | Nan Lanahan | Sandy Weckter |
| 2019 | Pat Mayne | Sandy Weckter |
| 2018 | Anne Van Buren | Sandy Weckter |
| 2017 | Anne Van Buren | Caroline Merritt |
| 2016 | Mary Scatena | Gail Brophy |
| 2015 | Heather Morrison | Dee Foley |
| 2014 | Pat Mayne | Pam Farhart |
| 2013 | Pat Mayne | Gail Brophy |
| 2012 | Gail Brophy | Gail Brophy |
| 2011 | Sandy Drahusak | M J Ellis |
| 2010 | Linda Kolnick | Ilene Gaffney |
| 2009 | Leslie Arakelian | Sue Herrick |
| 2008 | Leslie Arakelian | Joan Taylor |
| 2007 | Leslie Arakelian | Joan Taylor |
| 2006 | Linda Kolnick | Betty Heller |
| 2005 | Linda Kolnick | Audrey Van Alstine |
| 2004 | Linda Kolnick | Audrey Van Alstine |
| 2003 | Jan Vincent | Audrey Van Alstine |
| 2002 | Linda Kolnick | Audrey Van Alstine |
| 2001 | Jan Vincent | Louise Starzenski & Audrey Van Alstine |
| 2000 | Joyce Martin | Louise Starzenski |
| 1999 | Jan Vincent | Louise Starzenski |
| 1998 | Karen Krug | Louise Starzenski |
| 1997 | Jan Vincent | |
| 1996 | Alice Baker | |
| 1995 | Alice Baker |